News · Sports For Subscribers Red Sox Pitcher Payton Tolle Rips Ketchup on Steak: “You’re Harming the Cow and the Cow’s Already Dead” Red Sox pitcher Payton Tolle is no fan of ketchup on steak, calling it “an atrocity” and saying it belongs nowhere near it. By Tom Joyce April 28, 2026 · 5:33 AM EDT · 2 min read read Advertisement Red Sox pitcher Payton Tolle is no fan of ketchup on steak, calling it “an atrocity” and saying it belongs nowhere near it. Advertisement